Short answer: If your tank water heater is more than about 10 years old and is leaking from the tank, putting rust into your hot water, or no longer keeping up, replacement is usually the better call. A younger unit with a single failed part, such as a thermostat, heating element or valve, is often worth repairing. A licensed plumber can tell you which situation you're in after one visit.

Water heating is one of the bigger energy costs in a home. Ohio State University's Green Home program puts it at roughly 18% of a home's utility bill. So when the unit starts acting up, it's worth deciding on purpose instead of waiting for a cold shower or a flooded garage.

How long does a water heater last?

There's no fixed expiration date, but 10 years is the common point where people start planning a replacement. ENERGY STAR's guidance is direct: if your water heater is over 10 years old, replace it before it fails rather than after. Hard water, a long stretch without maintenance and heavy use can all shorten that.

To find your unit's age, look at the label on the tank. The manufacture date is usually printed there or coded into the serial number. The manufacturer's website or customer service line can decode it for you.

What are the signs a water heater needs to be replaced?

The City of Lakewood Village, Texas lists five common warning signs:

  • Visible corrosion on the tank or around the water line connections.
  • Water leaking from a joint, seal or seam.
  • Rust in your hot water, which points to corrosion inside the tank.
  • Not enough hot water, often because sediment has built up in the bottom of the tank.
  • Rumbling or popping noises, usually caused by that same sediment.

Some of these are repairable and some aren't. A drip from a fitting or valve can often be fixed. A leak from the tank itself can't be patched. Once the tank is rusting through, it's time for a new one.

When does a repair make sense?

A repair is usually reasonable when:

  • The unit is well under 10 years old.
  • The problem is a single part: a thermostat, heating element, gas control valve, igniter or a leaking fitting.
  • The tank itself is dry and free of rust.

Replacement is usually the better choice when:

  • The tank is leaking or rusting.
  • The unit is past 10 years and needs a repair that costs a meaningful share of what a new unit would.
  • You've had several repairs in the past couple of years.
  • Your household has outgrown it. The U.S. Department of Energy has a guide to sizing a new water heater based on your peak-hour use.

What should I know before buying a new one?

Consider a heat pump water heater if you have an electric tank. According to ENERGY STAR, a certified heat pump water heater uses less than half the energy of a standard electric storage water heater. ENERGY STAR estimates savings for a four-person household at about $330 a year, based on 12-cent electricity. Your savings will depend on your rates and how much hot water you use.

Don't count on the old federal tax credit. The Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (25C) that covered heat pump water heaters ended. The IRS says the credit is not allowed for property placed in service after December 31, 2025. Some utilities still run their own rebates, so check your electric or gas company's website before you buy.

Tankless units need maintenance too. In areas with hard water, manufacturers recommend periodically flushing and descaling the heat exchanger.

What can I do myself?

  • Check the temperature setting. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends setting water heaters to 120°F to help prevent scalding. A lower setting also cuts standby heat loss.
  • Look for moisture around the base of the tank and the pipe connections every few months.
  • Know where the shutoffs are. Find the cold water valve on top of the tank, plus the gas valve or the circuit breaker, before you have an emergency.
  • Follow your owner's manual on flushing. Draining sediment is a common maintenance step, but on an old tank it can stir up debris or reveal a valve that won't reseal. If you're unsure, have a plumber do it.

When should I call a pro?

Call a licensed plumber right away if you see water coming from the tank, smell gas, see scorch marks near a gas burner, or notice water or steam coming from the temperature and pressure relief valve. Turn off the water supply and the power or gas first.

You should also call a pro for any replacement. Gas venting, relief valve discharge lines, expansion tanks and electrical connections are code items, and most areas require a permit. Before you hire, it's worth checking the contractor's license.

If you're looking for a locally owned plumber, you can browse plumbing companies on Service Pro Spotlight, including pros in Texas, Florida, Arizona and North Carolina.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a tank water heater usually last?

Many last around 10 years or longer, depending on water quality and maintenance. ENERGY STAR recommends replacing a water heater that's more than 10 years old before it fails.

Can a leaking water heater be repaired?

It depends on where the leak is coming from. A leaking fitting or valve can often be repaired. A leak from the tank itself can't be fixed, and the unit needs to be replaced.

Is there still a federal tax credit for a heat pump water heater?

No, not for new installs. The IRS says the 25C credit is not allowed for property placed in service after December 31, 2025. Check with your local utility for rebates.

What temperature should my water heater be set to?

The CPSC recommends 120°F to reduce the risk of scalding.